Biased article didn’t put what Netanyahu said after, totally roasted Macron.
Unicorn_Colombo on
Macron doesn’t know much history, does it? Israel would be created by UN decision if Palestinian Arabs accepted the UN plan. They didn’t. Instead, civil war erupted and Britain said “fick it, I am going home”. Then Israel declared independence and fought several wars for it.
> Tensions have increased between Netanyahu and Macron with the French leader last week insisting that stopping the export of weapons used by Israel in Gaza and Lebanon was the only way to stop the conflicts.
> "Mr Netanyahu must not forget that his country was created by a decision of the UN," Macron told the weekly French cabinet meeting, referring to the resolution adopted in November 1947 by the United Nations General Assembly on the plan to partition Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state.
Was it UN that defended Israel when 7 Arab countries attacked it on the day it was “created by UN decision”?
What a clown
southpolefiesta on
It was not.
UN proposal was never accepter or approved.
Israel is self created.
bobsbottlerocket on
wow this was an incredibly stupid thing of him to say lol
SlightAppearance3337 on
And then the UN sent peacekeepers to defend said UN decision which was respected by Arab nations, right?
SuspiciousFishRunner on
Isn’t he married to his former teacher?
He must have flunked history.
qksv on
No, it wasn’t. What an idiot.
HeadFund on
Macron being deliberately arrogant and inflammatory with false history
MrBobSacamano on
Oh, yeah. This will go well…
KLei2020 on
The audacity of Macron.
aftemoon_coffee on
France must have forgotten its history when they tried to stop Jews from living in its ancestral lands in the 1800s and inflamed Jew hatred as a way to limit British influence in the region and control of resources. But go off macron
txipper on
Macron: just wait until your father gets home.
RegretfullyRI on
Fuckin burn!
Distinct_Pilot_3687 on
United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181
November 29, 1947
I do think that while we’re acknowledging that fact then we must also acknowledge the fact that the UN was not fair in how they gave them that land. Their actions caused the current inevitability to occur in the first place.
The only reason why the UN handed that land to them was because of the lack of organized government. Thats it. If the Palestinians had what modern world at the time deemed a functional government, boy oh boy would this be real different.
stilusmobilus on
*We had joy*
*We had fun*
*We beat Israel 4-1*
Now this comment, ice cold Macron.
skeleton949 on
Israel was created by the people in the area, not by the useless UN.
Ahad_Haam on
Israel absolutely wasn’t created by a UN decision. The UNGA voted in favor of partition, true, but UNGA votes don’t worth the paper they are written on. It was a recommendation for action by the security council, which never carried it out.
Israel had zero help from the UN during the Independence War.
[deleted] on
[removed]
Bluunbottle on
And the comeback? Well, if your country didn’t actively assist in the Holocaust, maybe we wouldn’t be having this conversation.
Sabina_wanton on
When the worst person you know made a great point.
Also, a french president denying weapons from Israel to appease the Arab, not the first time:
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherbourg_Project](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherbourg_Project)
crocodilesareforwimp on
So is Macron suddenly talking about Israel all the time now to distract people from his failing presidency and idiotic political maneuvering or what?
LordFUHard on
Israelis are like the replicants.
Ooh..is that bad thing to say?
They did get memories inserted into them though, like they were chosen by god or some shit like that.
thowaywaya108266 on
Israel really needs to watch itself. Saber-rattling without any sense of diplomacy or cooperation is how you become a pariah state. Does North Korea’s nuclear arsenal make anyone like them anymore, or do we simply roll our eyes and say “yeah OK weirdo, please f*ck off now”?
Few_Satisfaction2601 on
What’s it gonna do? USA and EU keeps feeding the monster no matter what. You killed our civilian citizen in Gaza? Np, here is some more bombs.
All about the fucking money lol. That’s what happens when your biggest financial contributors and the media is owned by them.
Scientifiction77 on
What a fucking idiot
Such_Lobster1426 on
Uhm… I guess that means France should do whatever the US, Russia or the UK says because they are the only reason the French aren’t speaking German?
Twootwootwoo on
Not true, they won many wars to ensure their independence. Also, France is a country created by the Anglos after WW2, otherwise it would have remained Germany on the north and a German puppet on the south or the Anglos could have done anything after winning the war, they were very generous with France and tried to keep French honor at all time when they didn’t have to.
31 Comments
Biased article didn’t put what Netanyahu said after, totally roasted Macron.
Macron doesn’t know much history, does it? Israel would be created by UN decision if Palestinian Arabs accepted the UN plan. They didn’t. Instead, civil war erupted and Britain said “fick it, I am going home”. Then Israel declared independence and fought several wars for it.
What a moronic thing to say.
This is the best tl;dr I could make, [original](https://www.france24.com/en/middle-east/20241015-in-clash-with-netanyahu-macron-says-israel-pm-mustn-t-forget-his-country-created-by-un-decision) reduced by 55%. (I’m a bot)
*****
> By: NEWS WIRES. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu should not forget his country was created as a result of a resolution adopted by the United Nations, French President Emmanuel Macron told cabinet on Tuesday, urging Israel to abide by UN decisions.
> Tensions have increased between Netanyahu and Macron with the French leader last week insisting that stopping the export of weapons used by Israel in Gaza and Lebanon was the only way to stop the conflicts.
> "Mr Netanyahu must not forget that his country was created by a decision of the UN," Macron told the weekly French cabinet meeting, referring to the resolution adopted in November 1947 by the United Nations General Assembly on the plan to partition Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state.
*****
[**Extended Summary**](http://np.reddit.com/r/autotldr/comments/1g4dw9r/in_clash_with_netanyahu_macron_says_israel_pm/) | [FAQ](http://np.reddit.com/r/autotldr/comments/31b9fm/faq_autotldr_bot/ “Version 2.02, ~695062 tl;drs so far.”) | [Feedback](http://np.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%23autotldr “PM’s and comments are monitored, constructive feedback is welcome.”) | *Top* *keywords*: **French**^#1 **Lebanon**^#2 **Netanyahu**^#3 **peacekeepers**^#4 **deployed**^#5
Was it UN that defended Israel when 7 Arab countries attacked it on the day it was “created by UN decision”?
What a clown
It was not.
UN proposal was never accepter or approved.
Israel is self created.
wow this was an incredibly stupid thing of him to say lol
And then the UN sent peacekeepers to defend said UN decision which was respected by Arab nations, right?
Isn’t he married to his former teacher?
He must have flunked history.
No, it wasn’t. What an idiot.
Macron being deliberately arrogant and inflammatory with false history
Oh, yeah. This will go well…
The audacity of Macron.
France must have forgotten its history when they tried to stop Jews from living in its ancestral lands in the 1800s and inflamed Jew hatred as a way to limit British influence in the region and control of resources. But go off macron
Macron: just wait until your father gets home.
Fuckin burn!
United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181
November 29, 1947
https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/res181.asp
Well gawd dam!
I do think that while we’re acknowledging that fact then we must also acknowledge the fact that the UN was not fair in how they gave them that land. Their actions caused the current inevitability to occur in the first place.
The only reason why the UN handed that land to them was because of the lack of organized government. Thats it. If the Palestinians had what modern world at the time deemed a functional government, boy oh boy would this be real different.
*We had joy*
*We had fun*
*We beat Israel 4-1*
Now this comment, ice cold Macron.
Israel was created by the people in the area, not by the useless UN.
Israel absolutely wasn’t created by a UN decision. The UNGA voted in favor of partition, true, but UNGA votes don’t worth the paper they are written on. It was a recommendation for action by the security council, which never carried it out.
Israel had zero help from the UN during the Independence War.
[removed]
And the comeback? Well, if your country didn’t actively assist in the Holocaust, maybe we wouldn’t be having this conversation.
When the worst person you know made a great point.
Also, a french president denying weapons from Israel to appease the Arab, not the first time:
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherbourg_Project](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherbourg_Project)
So is Macron suddenly talking about Israel all the time now to distract people from his failing presidency and idiotic political maneuvering or what?
Israelis are like the replicants.
Ooh..is that bad thing to say?
They did get memories inserted into them though, like they were chosen by god or some shit like that.
Israel really needs to watch itself. Saber-rattling without any sense of diplomacy or cooperation is how you become a pariah state. Does North Korea’s nuclear arsenal make anyone like them anymore, or do we simply roll our eyes and say “yeah OK weirdo, please f*ck off now”?
What’s it gonna do? USA and EU keeps feeding the monster no matter what. You killed our civilian citizen in Gaza? Np, here is some more bombs.
All about the fucking money lol. That’s what happens when your biggest financial contributors and the media is owned by them.
What a fucking idiot
Uhm… I guess that means France should do whatever the US, Russia or the UK says because they are the only reason the French aren’t speaking German?
Not true, they won many wars to ensure their independence. Also, France is a country created by the Anglos after WW2, otherwise it would have remained Germany on the north and a German puppet on the south or the Anglos could have done anything after winning the war, they were very generous with France and tried to keep French honor at all time when they didn’t have to.