Minimum unit pricing doesn’t stop the hardcore alcoholics. They’ll just keep buying it even though it’s more expensive and resort to more desperate measures to get their next fix (theft, dodgy homebrews ect ..)
denyer-no1-fan on
>A report by the Lancet last year found minimum unit pricing in Scotland was associated with a 13.4% reduction in deaths wholly attributable to alcohol consumption. Public Health Scotland said there was no clear evidence of substantial negative impacts on the alcoholic drinks industry.
If it works in Scotland, seems sensible to introduce it in England. Reducing alcohol harm is good for everyone.
JudasPreist1999 on
it doesn’t work and its based on a complete lie, that this would only affect hard drinkers and not everyone, it does affect everyone , and its regressive
CurtisInCamden on
The price disparity between supermarkets and pubs has gotten ridiculous and so hopefully this might reverse the decline of the pub/hospitality industry. Prices in pubs/bars/restaurants have at least doubled (even tripled sometimes) over the past 20 years, but at my local big-name supermarket I can buy a 4 pack of own-brand beer for under £3, slightly cheaper than 20 years ago (vastly cheaper after inflation).
Matt_2504 on
Why should normal people be forced to pay higher prices just because of a minority who can’t control themselves?
Worldly_Table_5092 on
500% tax chocolate, 500% tax cigs, 500% tax booze. Maximum health. 0 fun allowed.
UK_username on
Maybe it’s not the alcohol but what has pushed 10% more to drink it to excess. Like government induced austerity, cutting public services, and cost of living crysis, probably 100s of examples why more people are trying to numb the pain.
humblevessell on
Alcohol is already way more expensive here than in France, Germany and many other countries this is ridiculous.
Gazz1e on
Nanny state. The fraction of a percent of people have no control over themselves and it impacts the rest of us. Europeans have beers stronger than ours at a cheaper price.
SharpEssay5991 on
If raising the price of alcohol worked, it would’ve worked in Turkey. People who can afford it will continue to buy and drink and people who can’t afford turn to cheaper and more harmful drugs.
dahid on
Trust me, price doesn’t do anything unless you made it £100 a bottle. Alcoholics will spend all the money they have if they can afford it, it’s the same with any addiction, price does not factor into their reasoning for purchasing it.
Alcohol is super expensive in Finland due to taxes and they still have a big alcohol problem.
Ok-Importance-6815 on
if you raise the price of alcohol people will just stop buying their kids vegetables
TouristPuzzled2169 on
We drink ourselves to death because its so very very shit to live here NOT because booze is too cheap.
SnoopyLupus on
My Dad died this year. They’re probably counting him twice!
Akkinak on
Don’t put a minimum price as that only benefits the seller, put more tax on it so that the extra money is taken as tax rather than profit for the few.
Thebritishdovah on
If someone wants to get pissed, they will get pissed. I knew an alcoholic who could barely walk and would beg taxi drivers to get him booze from the local shop.
Price won’t deter them. It does punish everyone else. I rarely drink and paying a minimum based on units would likely make it too dam expensive to get wankered once a month at a wrestling show. It’s the one thing I look forward to and getting wankered is a side effect of having a good time.
Raddish53 on
Another veiled reason to increase taxes. Surely all these rises in death rates over the decades, used by politicians as low hanging fruit, must add up to 110% guaranteed death from drinking any kind of alcohol.
Considering the prices are as high because of previous numbers drinking themselves to death, then that system must not be working in fact previous price rises have been part in a 10% rise In people drinking themselves to death.
Soulless--Plague on
I’ve seen people drink hand sanitiser. This won’t stop people if they are alcoholics
Apez_in_Space on
Pubs and bars tend to have staff that’ll kick out or stop serving people if they get too drunk (obviously not always but we’re talking about deaths from alcohol abuse here). Here’s an idea: reduce tariffs at bars whilst increasing at shops and supermarkets. Do something to preserve our pubs as a benefit for tackling the problem at the source.
OHCHEEKY on
Or try fixing the reasons that drive people to alcohol abuse in the first place
LukePickle007 on
This is just going to make people move over to drugs instead.
ragged-bobyn-1972 on
maybe if the country wasnt a living nightmare people wouldnt drink so much.
Ricoh06 on
It’s national pastime culture, why does everything have to be bloody ruined and changed in this country?
toby1jabroni on
Making life less shitty in general helps keep the death rate down. Putting prices up doesn’t help with that at all and only makes things worse.
MDK1980 on
Like all those people who they thought would stop smoking once prices went up…
bahumat42 on
Maybe we could try improving society so people don’t feel the need to drink.
Honorable_Dead_Snark on
They’ll do anything rather than legalise cannabis won’t they? Despite some research in the states and Canada showing a link to decreased alcohol sales and lower rates of alcohol use disorder.Â
Ok_Annual3581 on
Yes! Why address our poor mental health support, or the atrocious costs of living, failing housing/nhs etc, when you can slap 10% on alcohol to ‘avoid deaths’. It’s laughable they think this won’t just have a further impact on crime rates etc.
WanderingLemon25 on
I’d rather we invested money & time as a nation considering why people resort to alcohol rather than just putting another tax on people who are already at rock bottom.Â
People resort to alcohol/drugs because life is that miserable working 40 hours a week for faceless corporations who suck everything they can from the system, exploit people everywhere they can and reward the top 0.1% excessively rather than fairly across the board, all while trying to get away with paying as little tax as possible leading to poor community services, high crime rates to pay for things and depressing places to live.Â
If only politicians/thinktanks gave a fuck about any of this rather than how do we suck even more from people.
Sickening
Pizzagoessplat on
Fuxk no.
If they’re going to do it is should be for products over 10% or something on those lines.
Currently live in Ireland whee we have it and I buy a bottle of vodka instead of a case of beer because it’s cheaper!!!
nekrovulpes on
Fuck off, it’s already expensive enough. Maybe make life in general less miserable and people wouldn’t drink themselves to death. All this kind of shit does is make it even more miserable for the average person seeing more and more of the few little pleasures we have left getting priced out of our reach.
Lando7373 on
All the ‘anti-anything fun or enjoyable’ losers will be out in force on this thread. Miserable fucks.
Tricky_Reporter_2269 on
Perhaps its a symptom of helplessness/hoplessness a lot of people are feeling these days?
33 Comments
Minimum unit pricing doesn’t stop the hardcore alcoholics. They’ll just keep buying it even though it’s more expensive and resort to more desperate measures to get their next fix (theft, dodgy homebrews ect ..)
>A report by the Lancet last year found minimum unit pricing in Scotland was associated with a 13.4% reduction in deaths wholly attributable to alcohol consumption. Public Health Scotland said there was no clear evidence of substantial negative impacts on the alcoholic drinks industry.
If it works in Scotland, seems sensible to introduce it in England. Reducing alcohol harm is good for everyone.
it doesn’t work and its based on a complete lie, that this would only affect hard drinkers and not everyone, it does affect everyone , and its regressive
The price disparity between supermarkets and pubs has gotten ridiculous and so hopefully this might reverse the decline of the pub/hospitality industry. Prices in pubs/bars/restaurants have at least doubled (even tripled sometimes) over the past 20 years, but at my local big-name supermarket I can buy a 4 pack of own-brand beer for under £3, slightly cheaper than 20 years ago (vastly cheaper after inflation).
Why should normal people be forced to pay higher prices just because of a minority who can’t control themselves?
500% tax chocolate, 500% tax cigs, 500% tax booze. Maximum health. 0 fun allowed.
Maybe it’s not the alcohol but what has pushed 10% more to drink it to excess. Like government induced austerity, cutting public services, and cost of living crysis, probably 100s of examples why more people are trying to numb the pain.
Alcohol is already way more expensive here than in France, Germany and many other countries this is ridiculous.
Nanny state. The fraction of a percent of people have no control over themselves and it impacts the rest of us. Europeans have beers stronger than ours at a cheaper price.
If raising the price of alcohol worked, it would’ve worked in Turkey. People who can afford it will continue to buy and drink and people who can’t afford turn to cheaper and more harmful drugs.
Trust me, price doesn’t do anything unless you made it £100 a bottle. Alcoholics will spend all the money they have if they can afford it, it’s the same with any addiction, price does not factor into their reasoning for purchasing it.
Alcohol is super expensive in Finland due to taxes and they still have a big alcohol problem.
if you raise the price of alcohol people will just stop buying their kids vegetables
We drink ourselves to death because its so very very shit to live here NOT because booze is too cheap.
My Dad died this year. They’re probably counting him twice!
Don’t put a minimum price as that only benefits the seller, put more tax on it so that the extra money is taken as tax rather than profit for the few.
If someone wants to get pissed, they will get pissed. I knew an alcoholic who could barely walk and would beg taxi drivers to get him booze from the local shop.
Price won’t deter them. It does punish everyone else. I rarely drink and paying a minimum based on units would likely make it too dam expensive to get wankered once a month at a wrestling show. It’s the one thing I look forward to and getting wankered is a side effect of having a good time.
Another veiled reason to increase taxes. Surely all these rises in death rates over the decades, used by politicians as low hanging fruit, must add up to 110% guaranteed death from drinking any kind of alcohol.
Considering the prices are as high because of previous numbers drinking themselves to death, then that system must not be working in fact previous price rises have been part in a 10% rise In people drinking themselves to death.
I’ve seen people drink hand sanitiser. This won’t stop people if they are alcoholics
Pubs and bars tend to have staff that’ll kick out or stop serving people if they get too drunk (obviously not always but we’re talking about deaths from alcohol abuse here). Here’s an idea: reduce tariffs at bars whilst increasing at shops and supermarkets. Do something to preserve our pubs as a benefit for tackling the problem at the source.
Or try fixing the reasons that drive people to alcohol abuse in the first place
This is just going to make people move over to drugs instead.
maybe if the country wasnt a living nightmare people wouldnt drink so much.
It’s national pastime culture, why does everything have to be bloody ruined and changed in this country?
Making life less shitty in general helps keep the death rate down. Putting prices up doesn’t help with that at all and only makes things worse.
Like all those people who they thought would stop smoking once prices went up…
Maybe we could try improving society so people don’t feel the need to drink.
They’ll do anything rather than legalise cannabis won’t they? Despite some research in the states and Canada showing a link to decreased alcohol sales and lower rates of alcohol use disorder.Â
Yes! Why address our poor mental health support, or the atrocious costs of living, failing housing/nhs etc, when you can slap 10% on alcohol to ‘avoid deaths’. It’s laughable they think this won’t just have a further impact on crime rates etc.
I’d rather we invested money & time as a nation considering why people resort to alcohol rather than just putting another tax on people who are already at rock bottom.Â
People resort to alcohol/drugs because life is that miserable working 40 hours a week for faceless corporations who suck everything they can from the system, exploit people everywhere they can and reward the top 0.1% excessively rather than fairly across the board, all while trying to get away with paying as little tax as possible leading to poor community services, high crime rates to pay for things and depressing places to live.Â
If only politicians/thinktanks gave a fuck about any of this rather than how do we suck even more from people.
Sickening
Fuxk no.
If they’re going to do it is should be for products over 10% or something on those lines.
Currently live in Ireland whee we have it and I buy a bottle of vodka instead of a case of beer because it’s cheaper!!!
Fuck off, it’s already expensive enough. Maybe make life in general less miserable and people wouldn’t drink themselves to death. All this kind of shit does is make it even more miserable for the average person seeing more and more of the few little pleasures we have left getting priced out of our reach.
All the ‘anti-anything fun or enjoyable’ losers will be out in force on this thread. Miserable fucks.
Perhaps its a symptom of helplessness/hoplessness a lot of people are feeling these days?