150 avoidable deaths: The controversies surrounding cardiac surgery at the University Hospital Zurich
In this video we shed light on the serious scandal surrounding cardiac surgery at the University Hospital of Zurich. Under the leadership of Francesco Maisano, at least 150 preventable deaths occurred between 2016 and 2020. We analyze the events and the far-reaching consequences that this scandal brings with it.
What we treat:
• The events: The cardiac surgery under Francesco Maisano was heavily criticized for the use of controversial implants and incorrect treatment. We show how these practices led to increased mortality. • Expert opinions: Thierry Carrel, a renowned heart surgeon, estimates that between 100 and 200 patients would have survived if a different procedure had been performed. Paul Vogt, Maisano’s successor, speaks of serious unethical behavior during Maisano’s tenure. • Reactions and measures: Health Director Natalie Rickli sees no threat to patient welfare, while compensation was paid to those affected who had to sign confidentiality agreements. We are investigating why no criminal proceedings were initiated despite the serious allegations. • Documentation and evidence: A former USZ heart surgeon presented extensive evidence, including emails and letters to the Health Directorate, and filed a criminal complaint. We show how these documents reveal the abuses.
Sources:
1. Inside Paradeplatz – “Horror report about university hospital heart causes panic attacks”
This article reports on the explosive report by 24 experts, which reveals the serious deficiencies in cardiac surgery at the University Hospital of Zurich. It highlights the increased mortality rates and the critical reactions to the revelations. Read here
- Tages-Anzeiger – “USZ auditors take action after university hospital affair involving Maisano”
The Tages-Anzeiger provides an overview of the ongoing audits and investigations regarding the allegations against Francesco Maisano and those responsible at the University Hospital. Read here
Posted by lehar1